Stephan Mairesse ← All articles
Training methods

Do You Realize You're Caging Your Dog?

Crate training is sold to you as the solution for house training, separation anxiety, and destructive behavior. But there is no problem it claims to solve that can't be solved instead by respecting rules of life — and what it actually asks you to do is lock your dog in a cage.

Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.

See the course

Here's what actually happens, and it's entirely natural, when you welcome a puppy home. He explores the world through his mouth, so he starts chewing on whatever is within reach. He also starts playing with you — mouthing you, nibbling you harder and harder as he grows. Because he's young, he isn't house trained yet. And because nobody explained to you — or you simply didn't know — what needs to be done to prevent separation anxiety, dogs very often start showing signs of it. These behaviors develop quite naturally for a puppy. And as he grows, a dog can also start showing aggression, start destroying things, or stop being house trained — these too can surface with age, and again, because of an absence of rules of life.

Your dog isn't house trained? Crate. He destroys things? Crate. He's too excited and you can't calm him down? Crate. He has separation anxiety? Crate. He mouths you? Crate.

Today, crate training is recommended to you for house training, for separation anxiety, and for destructive behavior. But before going further into the subject, ask yourself this: do you realize you're being sold an education method that consists of locking your dog in a cage? It doesn't solve the problem — it masks it. And if the crate does produce results in one area, the root cause behind them will simply resurface somewhere else.

Why crate training became so popular

When I started this profession 30 years ago, people were shocked when they saw someone using a cage. Then some breeders began recommending it. It spread more and more — why? Because owners couldn't find an effective solution to educate their dogs, so they were told to crate them instead. That's completely absurd.

And here's the irony: the same trainers and behaviorists who deny hierarchy, and who call it scandalous that you'd impose rules of life on your dog, have no problem at all telling you to put him in a small box — and selling you that as a method. You call rules of life mistreatment? You cage dogs.

Are we back in the Middle Ages? You're told it's temporary — but temporary for how long, exactly? And maybe, rightly so, you simply don't want to confine your dog at all.

What actually solves these problems — without a cage

Here's the principle behind the solution — it's broken down step by step in the course.

Imposing a framework, a structure, rules of life, isn't just fundamental to a dog's balance — it solves every one of these problems, and it solves them well, fast, and effectively. I've offered an effective, fast, and lasting solution for raising a puppy or managing an adult dog for 30 years, and I have never once used a crate. That solution is built on rules of life around four pillars I didn't invent — I observed them within packs of dogs.

But the mainstream narrative tells you that the "alpha roll" and "dominance" are harsh on a dog — even dismissed outright as a myth. What nobody explains to you is what dominance actually means; it's simply demonized. Dominance has nothing to do with brutality or violence — it means your dog has someone who takes charge of him, who leads the group, and it's that leadership that puts him at ease. In practice, dominating a dog means establishing rules of life, around food, space, physical contact, and reproduction. It's the opposite of mistreatment: it's respecting a social structure that's fundamental to a dog's well-being, whatever specific problem you're facing. Apply it, and problems that have already appeared resolve quickly; if they hadn't appeared yet, they won't.

This isn't a method I invented — it's backed by scientists who've spent their careers studying it:

"Being subordinate does not mean being humiliated: it means being protected by the group and feeling secure."

Patrick Pageat (1999) — veterinary behaviorist, founder and scientific director of IRSEA.

"There are debates today among behaviorists — some say the hierarchy isn't real. They're wrong. You have to get into the hierarchy: if you don't do your job as pack leader, you're going to be in trouble. When you know the dog well, there's no question about it — it isn't for the dog to decide where he goes or what he eats. He shouldn't be the leader, because if you give him room and he's a bit of a wolf around the edges, he'll take the place of pack leader, and you'll have nothing more to say. You have to accept the hierarchy."

Pierre Jouventin (2015) — ethologist, former CNRS Research Director.

"Providing clear and consistent leadership for a dog is not tyranny, but a reassuring framing duty that frees the animal from the burden of managing its domestic environment."

Bertrand L. Deputte (2008, p. 88) — ethologist, École Nationale Vétérinaire d'Alfort.

"Dogs are not biologically adapted to a permissive or 'democratic' approach granted by most owners. Applying principles of authority and hierarchy saves packs and individual animals, creates domestic stability, and relieves chronic anxiety. The role of leader requires firmness and control, and must never be confused with aggressiveness."

Dr. Melvyn Greenberg (2018) — veterinary surgeon and ethologist.

House training

There is no problem the crate claims to solve that can't be solved by respecting rules of life. For every client who has called me about house training, it has been resolved by 3 to 4 months of age — sometimes it takes until 5 months, but never later than that. None of them ever needed a crate for it.

Separation anxiety

Putting your dog in a small box doesn't resolve separation anxiety. While it seems to work on some dogs — and that's exactly where the trap lies — it will generate another problem elsewhere, because the root cause hasn't been treated. The argument you're given is: "But it becomes their comfort zone — proof is, when you leave the crate door open, they go back in on their own." A comfort zone, though, isn't automatically a healthy one, and everyone actually knows this. Humans have relationships that are their comfort zone and are still toxic relationships.

Here's a concrete example. When I run animal-therapy workshops in prison with dogs, I talk with the inmates. Several of them told me the same thing: "The outside world — I'm not comfortable in it at all. I'm more comfortable in prison. I'd rather go back than be outside." That is their comfort zone. Would anyone call that a healthy one? A dog going back into his open cage doesn't mean it's healthy for him. I don't think it is, not for a second.

And separation anxiety isn't resolved by artificially creating distance through confinement — it's resolved by imposing a clear framework of rules of life.

Destructive behavior

The same applies here: there are education methods that let your dog move freely while resolving destructive behavior. Putting him in a cage only prevents it while he's locked up — it doesn't address why he's doing it in the first place. The crate exists because no one offered you a real, effective training solution. So instead, you're told to lock him up — and, without questioning it, you do.

An excited dog

Obedience can calm him down immediately — asking him to stay on his mat, for example. But if you want your dog to obey you correctly, he needs to see you as his leader, the one who has the authority to do so.

Mouthing and biting

Does your dog chase after you to bite your shoes, your clothes, your ankles? This can be stopped within a day — you just have to learn a gesture to do it. But if your dog isn't led by you, if he thinks he has authority over you, then he can initiate any physical contact with you however he wants — including snapping at you — and you won't have a say in it.

Resignation isn't calm

Watch a puppy's reaction the very first time he's put in a crate — it's not something healthy. Over time, once a dog understands he cannot get out, he resigns himself and eventually lies down, even sleeps. That resignation is often mistaken for comfort. But it isn't comfort — it's giving up.

And it doesn't happen for every dog. I regularly get calls from clients — never because I recommended the crate, I never have — who tell me: "I use the crate, but my dog spends his time howling, barking, or destroying it, because he can't stand being inside." I tell them immediately: I've worked for 30 years and never once needed this method. I find it barbaric — a genuine confinement in a small box — and not healthy in any way.

Why does this happen? Because without structuring rules, a dog is left holding the power — which makes locking him in a box completely contradictory on its own terms. And from a human standpoint, is confinement really a tolerable training method?

What this really exposes

This isn't just about the crate. It's what 100%-positive methods have to offer once you strip away the marketing: treats, and a cage. Is that really a decent training method? It's genuinely pitiful that these training systems dismiss field practitioners who've actually observed hierarchy firsthand — and have nothing better to offer in its place.

In Bali, plenty of Westerners are shocked to see dogs kept in cages — and they're right to be. It's worth asking why that same reaction doesn't carry over to the crate sitting in their own living room.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is crate training cruel?

Yes — it is a genuine confinement in a small box. There is no problem it claims to solve that can't be solved instead by respecting rules of life, which is why, after 30 years and more than 2,000 dogs trained, Stephan Mairesse has never once needed to use it.

Does crate training help with separation anxiety?

No — putting a dog in a small box doesn't resolve separation anxiety, it only creates artificial distance. Some dogs appear to settle into it, but a comfort zone isn't automatically a healthy one: separation anxiety is resolved by imposing a clear framework of rules of life, not by confinement.

Why does my dog destroy his crate, bark, or howl in it?

Because he can't stand being confined. Not every dog resigns himself to the cage — some fight it the whole time, howling, barking, or destroying it, which is the opposite of the "comfort zone" crate training is sold as.

Is crate training necessary for house training or stopping destructive behavior?

No — there is no problem crate training claims to solve, including house training and destruction, that can't be solved by respecting rules of life instead.

What should I do instead of crate training?

Apply rules of life — a structure built around four pillars: food, space, physical contact, and reproduction. It defines clear leadership without force, and it resolves house training, separation anxiety, and destructive behavior directly, without ever needing to lock your dog in a box.

How many hours can I leave my dog in a crate?

There's no safe number of hours — that's the wrong question. A crate doesn't need a duration limit if you don't use one in the first place: rules of life solve house training, separation anxiety, and destructive behavior without ever putting a time limit on your dog's confinement.

Why does my dog cry in his crate at night?

A puppy crying in his crate at night is separation anxiety showing up in its purest form — and it's proof the crate doesn't solve it: he's locked inside it, and he keeps expressing anxiety anyway, crying and distressed. Waiting it out or timing how long he cries doesn't treat that. And even if the dog stops expressing anxiety, not expressing it doesn't mean it is solved — the problem will show up elsewhere. The fix is the same one that resolves separation anxiety during the day: applying rules of life, so he doesn't need to be locked up, day or night.

References (APA 7th Edition)

Stephan Mairesse

Stephan MairesseInternational Dog Trainer, 30 years of experience across 16 countries, more than 2,000 dogs trained. Certification N°750108. Read his full background →

Learn how to become your dog's leader — without treats and without pain — step by step, filmed with real dogs.

See the course