Stephan Mairesse ← All articles
Dominance & hierarchy

Does Dominating a Dog Mean Being Harsh?

No. Dominating your dog does not mean being mean to him or mistreating him — it means being protective. Dominance is a framework of rules in which a dog finds balance, security, and well-being, and inside which you can be incredibly affectionate toward him.

Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.

See the course

Dominating your dog does not mean that you are "mean" to him, or mistreating him. Rather, it means being protective — because by doing so, he relies on us for his safety, his security, his survival. We are in charge of him, not the reverse.

This isn't just my own observation — veterinary behaviorist Patrick Pageat describes the exact same mechanism in dogs:

"Being subordinate does not mean being humiliated: it means being protected by the group and feeling secure."

Patrick Pageat (1999) — veterinary behaviorist, founder and scientific director of IRSEA.

It's worth being precise about what dominance actually means in scientific terms — because it isn't force:

"Dominance is rather the fact that, in each pair of animals, the dominant has the power to inhibit the subordinate's behavior or to provoke an avoidance response in him."

Jean-Marie Giffroy (1998, as cited in Guyot, 2010, p. 40) — ethologist.

Responding to a dog's requests and desires (most of the time, it is not a desire to enjoy something, but a wish for power), letting him decide, and doing whatever he wants, gives him the task of being responsible for us — so he has to watch us, he thinks he has to manage us. And each time you ask him something, it will be contradictory in his understanding.

But being dominant doesn't prevent you from loving your dog, nor from petting him as often as you wish, nor from having deep feelings toward him — not at all. Dominating a dog means that you apply a framework of rules in which he will find his balance, security and well-being, and within which you can be incredibly affectionate toward him.

In fact, dominating a dog means loving him, because you respect his world and his canine needs. If you are truly seen as dominant by your dog, he will be deeply attached to you — because he is genetically programmed to follow a strong leader, as it gives him more chances to survive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does dominating a dog mean being harsh with him?

No — dominating a dog means being protective, not mean or mistreating him. It's a framework of rules in which he finds balance, security, and well-being.

Can you still love and pet a dominant dog?

Yes — being dominant doesn't prevent you from loving your dog, petting him as often as you wish, or having deep feelings toward him.

Why does a dog get deeply attached to a dominant owner?

Because he is genetically programmed to follow a strong leader, as it gives him more chances to survive — if he truly sees you as dominant, he becomes deeply attached to you.

What happens if you let your dog decide and do whatever he wants?

It gives him the responsibility of being in charge of you and of himself — a job the large majority of dogs don't have the temperament for. And even when they do, everyday life creates constant contradictions for them.

References (APA 7th Edition)

Stephan Mairesse

Stephan MairesseInternational Dog Trainer, 30 years of experience across 16 countries, more than 2,000 dogs trained. Certification N°750108. Read his full background →

Learn how to become your dog's leader — without treats and without pain — step by step, filmed with real dogs.

See the course