Dog Consent in Dog Training
The « dog consent » theory tells you to let your dog say « no » during training, claiming this builds trust and reduces anxiety. As appealing as it sounds, it is a totally anthropomorphic idea, it misidentifies where anxiety in dogs actually comes from, and in real-life situations it can be dangerous.
Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.
See the course
As appealing as the concept of "dog consent" may seem, it is highly detrimental to a dog's balance and can prove dangerous.
What does this theory say? By respecting « no » (from the dog), "you build deep trust, reduce anxiety, and foster an optimistic pet who willingly chooses to cooperate." Instead of demanding obedience through forced compliance, consent-based obedience treats these cues as invitations to work. The dog is given the right to say « no, I cannot do that right now, » and the trainer uses that "no" as valuable data to adjust the training plan.
If this theory were viable and beneficial for dogs in dog training, I would be the first to put it into practice. When I invite my dogs to play or be petted, I do not force the issue if they aren't in the mood. However, these invitations to interact are not "dog training." Dog training involves obedience (such as going to a mat, heel, recall, etc.) but also establishes the necessary foundation: Rules of Life.
But why is this « dog consent » a totally anthropomorphic idea — one that wouldn't even hold up in human society when it comes to Law, for example? It's a lie when it claims to respect the dog; it's a lie when it claims that « giving the dog the option to say no — to refuse — builds trust and reduces anxiety ».
Where Anxiety in Dogs Really Comes From
Where does anxiety come from in a dog when it's directly linked to the dog/master relationship? It arises from 3 main causes.
The first is an unclear hierarchical status: the dog sometimes holds power, and at other times it is taken away. Every single dog I have trained over 30 years has shed all signs of anxiety once its status was clarified. I have seen dogs engage in severe self-mutilation (the acme of anxiety) due to unclear hierarchical status — a problem that no chemical treatment could resolve — yet they stopped the behavior permanently within a few days after being dominated.
A clear status can take two forms: having total power or having none at all. However, and this is the second cause of anxiety, for a dog lacking the temperament to handle it, holding total power generates anxiety, as the responsibility that comes with such power is overwhelming. While theoretically possible (and potentially beneficial for its balance) to grant total power to a dog with the right temperament, in practice, it is not feasible. Why? Because if the dog holds all the power, it makes no sense to impose anything on it — it might eat off your plate, refuse to let you enter your own home, fail to understand why you won't let it follow you when you leave the house, and feel absolutely no obligation to obey you. Consequently, the status that inevitably prevents anxiety is that of the subordinate.
"Being subordinate does not mean being humiliated: it means being protected by the group and feeling secure."
Patrick Pageat (1999) — veterinary behaviorist, founder and scientific director of IRSEA.
This quote also shatters the idea that letting the dog decide fosters trust. Trust stems from the fact that a dog can rely on an individual who provides it with a chance of survival — this is part of its genetic programming — and that individual is its dominant. However, if this individual is sometimes the leader and sometimes not (by giving away his power to impose), this makes them unpredictable, and unpredictability and trust never go hand in hand. But feeling « safe » and « trust » go together.
"The dog is a social being; to thrive, it needs this hierarchical relationship to be constantly maintained — in feeding, in sleeping arrangements, and in physical contact. This is the only way to structure and soothe the animal."
Monique Bourdin (2010) — veterinary doctor, graduate of the Institut Pasteur in Paris, in charge of teaching and consultations on behavioral disorders at the Maisons-Alfort veterinary school.
"There are debates today among behaviorists — some say the hierarchy isn't real. They're wrong. You have to get into the hierarchy: if you don't do your job as pack leader, you're going to be in trouble. When you know the dog well, there's no question about it — it isn't for the dog to decide where he goes or what he eats. He shouldn't be the leader, because if you give him room and he's a bit of a wolf around the edges, he'll take the place of pack leader, and you'll have nothing more to say. You have to accept the hierarchy."
Pierre Jouventin (2015) — ethologist, former CNRS Research Director.
The third cause lies in the fact that the owner has not carried out the process of « detachment » (ceasing to respond to the dog's demands and not letting it initiate physical contact), which leads to separation anxiety. And this type of anxiety is solved by the same process which leads to... dominating a dog. But once again, there should be no back-and-forth in domination.
The "dog consent" theory claims to lead this animal to be « optimistic ». So a dog could be "hopeful, positive, or confident about the future." To assume that a dog operates within this system of thought is completely unreasonable and highly anthropomorphic. Can anyone know how a dog thinks? At the very least, it is an illusion; at the very most, it is completely pretentious.
Why Dog Consent Can Be Dangerous
Why did I write that « dog consent » can prove dangerous? The preachers of this theory say that the dog is given the right to say « no », to take « a pause » when asked to obey. Well... imagine the result if your dog is about to cross a road. If your dog is running toward someone who enters your house to bite... Those preachers might argue that this right to say « no » is given while training but not in real situations — which is totally absurd, because if you allowed your dog to say « no » while training him, how could you expect him to always say « yes » in real life?...
The « dog consent » theory is, of course, promoted by professionals who use treats to get a dog to obey. While denying the reality of hierarchy, they rely only on positive reinforcement. So when a dog is more attracted by something else than the treat, of course, he won't obey.
And to cover the glaring lack of effectiveness of these methods, a new trick is being played on you: "your dog is not disobeying, he is using the right he has been given to say... no!"
If these preachers spent as much time opening their eyes to the true nature of dogs as they do concocting all sorts of crackpot theories, dogs would be much better off.
As seductive and appealing as this « dog consent » looks in dog training, the results it gives are nothing but lies.
To conclude, I will quote William Shakespeare: « All that glitters is not gold ».
Frequently Asked Questions
What does the “dog consent” theory claim?
That respecting a dog's “no” during training builds deep trust, reduces anxiety, and fosters a dog who willingly chooses to cooperate.
Is “dog consent” training actually good for dogs?
No — it is a totally anthropomorphic idea that misidentifies where canine anxiety actually comes from, and it can be dangerous in real-life situations.
What are the real causes of anxiety in the dog/owner relationship?
It arises from three main causes, the first being an unclear hierarchical status — dogs with severe self-mutilation from unclear status stopped permanently within days once dominated, with no chemical treatment needed.
Who promotes the “dog consent” theory, and why?
Professionals who use treats to get a dog to obey — while denying the reality of hierarchy, they rely only on positive reinforcement. When a dog is more attracted by something else and disobeys, they call it the dog “using the right he's been given to say no,” instead of admitting the method failed.
References (APA 7th Edition)
- Pageat, P. (1999). L'Homme et le Chien : psychologie associée du chien et de l'homme [Man and Dog: Associated psychology of dog and man]. Éditions Odile Jacob.
- Jouventin, P. (2015, May 13). Le loup, le chien et l'homme… [Conference presentation]. Espace des sciences, Rennes, France. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4k2zkre1R6c
- Bourdin, M. (2010). Communication et troubles de la sociopathie [Communication and sociopathy disorders]. In T. Bedossa & B. L. Deputte (Eds.), Comportement et éducation du chien [Canine behavior and training]. Éditions Educagri.
Learn how to become your dog's leader — without treats and without pain — step by step, filmed with real dogs.
See the course
Stephan Mairesse