Does Your Dog Have to Obey You?
No — your dog doesn't have to obey you, not until you've earned the power to be obeyed. That power comes from the rules of life: controlling food, territory, contact, and sexuality. Without them, obedience stays partial, and only happens when your dog feels like it.
Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.
See the courseDoes your dog stand on the couch with you? Do you pet him whenever he asks? Do you give him attention the moment you walk through the door? Then no — your dog doesn't have to obey you.
Your dog doesn't have to obey you, and he will do so only more or less partially, because if you give him power, it isn't logical for him to obey. You might have an illusion of obedience, because your dog can sometimes be obedient — but only when he is willing to. When he is not willing to, he won't. In fact, we can measure his level of obedience precisely when he is not willing to.
A dog has to obey his hierarchical superior — this is his logic. But it is ours too, and that of many species with a social organization.
Where the Power to Be Obeyed Comes From
Why do you obey a police officer, and not a child? Because a police officer intrinsically has the power to do so — the law gives it to him. So what gives you the power to be obeyed by a dog? Rules of life: controlling food, territory, contact, sexuality. It is in them that you gain the power to be obeyed, and in them that your dog understands that he has to.
Unless you apply the sum of all those rules, your dog doesn't have to obey you. So when he doesn't, don't get mad at him — ask yourself what you did wrong not to get him to obey.
Obedience Is Never Permanently Won
And once your dog obeys you, obedience is never definitively gained. I always tell my clients that obedience is a "living thing."
You reach landings that are never won for good. A lack of vigilance, a mistake, and your dog will exploit it to try to keep doing what he feels like doing. But your dog never forgets what you've taught him.
You can lose, very quickly, the level of obedience you've reached — but the good news is that you can get it back just as quickly. How? By becoming aware of the mistake that caused you to lose your level, and correcting it. Once that mistake is corrected, you will regain at least your previous level — or even reach a higher one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a dog have to obey its owner?
No — not until you've earned the power to be obeyed through the rules of life: controlling food, territory, contact, and sexuality.
Why would a dog only obey “when he feels like it”?
Because without applying all the rules of life, a dog's obedience stays partial — he obeys only when willing, and his true level of obedience is measured by what happens when he is not willing.
Where does the power to be obeyed come from?
From the rules of life — controlling food, territory, contact, and sexuality — the same way a police officer's authority comes from the law, not from the officer himself.
Why does a police officer get obeyed but a child doesn't?
Because a police officer intrinsically has the power to do so — the law gives it to him. The same logic applies to a dog: the power to be obeyed comes from the rules of life (food, territory, contact, sexuality), not from the person himself.
Is a dog's obedience permanent once you've earned it?
No — obedience is a living thing, not a fixed state. A lack of vigilance or a single mistake is enough for your dog to exploit it, but he never forgets what he's been taught, so you can regain your previous level, or even reach a higher one, as soon as you identify and correct the mistake.
Learn how to earn real obedience — without treats, step by step, filmed with real dogs.
See the course
Stephan Mairesse