Why Puppy Pads Don't Work
Puppy pads, crates, rigid schedules — the usual advice for house training is shaky at best, and often counterproductive. There are only 4 real reasons a dog isn't clean, and the fix for most of them isn't a tool, it's a set of rules of life.
Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.
See the courseCleanliness at a dog's scale, and at a human's
In a dog's world, being clean means not relieving himself where he sleeps — that part is instinctive. What he has to learn is cleanliness at a human scale: not relieving himself anywhere on the territory, meaning the whole house or apartment.
Why isn't my dog clean? 4 real reasons
Before anything else, rule out a medical cause — it's entirely possible, some pathologies or treatments can be behind it, but in my experience it's rare. One physiological case also sits outside all of this: a dog in a state of extreme fear can lose control and relieve himself involuntarily — there's no educational fix for that, it's physiological, not behavioral. The reverse also happens: a very frightened dog can hold it in for more than two days. Past the medical and the physiological, it almost always comes down to one of these four:
1. He's not old enough yet — his sphincter muscles simply aren't operational.
2. He learned cleanliness the wrong way — usually from puppy pads.
3. He holds power, or his status is ambivalent — a hierarchical cause.
4. Separation anxiety — if he's clean except when he's alone.
1. He's not old enough yet
In the first months, a puppy isn't clean simply because his sphincter muscles aren't operational enough yet. But accidents can still largely be prevented, because we know the pattern: a 2-month-old puppy can rarely hold it more than 2 hours while he's awake. That capacity lengthens progressively — around 3 months, he can hold it 3 to 4 hours, and so on.
A puppy relieves himself, as a rule, right after he's had something to drink, after playing, after eating, or after sleeping. Take him outside after every one of these moments, and you won't get accidents in the house. It takes time and attention, but it's entirely predictable. There's nothing else to do at this stage but wait for his body to catch up, and manage these moments.
2. He learned cleanliness the wrong way
This is usually linked to puppy pads — often recommended, and counterproductive. When you train a puppy on a pad, you're first teaching him that it's fine to relieve himself inside the house. Then you teach him to do it in one precise spot, where he gets rewarded.
Most people who've used this technique end up calling me and saying: "It worked really well — my dog would go on the pad. But once I removed it, he kept relieving himself in that same spot." That's because the dog wasn't praised for the pad alone, but for that whole part of the house: in his understanding, he's allowed to go there. Remove the pad, and he keeps going. Undoing that association is demanding, because you then have to block his access to that part of the house entirely.
Puppy pads don't just fail to work — they're actively counterproductive, because they teach a dog that relieving himself inside the house is acceptable. The crate is sold to solve the same problem, and fails the same way: a dog confined to a crate will be forced to hold it, because he won't relieve himself where he sleeps, but a large share of these dogs, the moment the crate is opened, go and relieve themselves elsewhere in the house. It suppresses the problem for as long as the door stays shut — it doesn't teach cleanliness.
3. He holds power, or his status is ambivalent
Either the dog holds power at home, and relieves himself to mark his territory — or his status is ambiguous. A typical example: he's allowed on the couch, but refused access to the bed. He's pushed away from the table because you don't want him begging, but then petted the moment he asks for it.
Each time you take power away from a dog after having given it to him, there's a risk. You give him power — letting him on the couch, for instance — and then you take some of it back — refusing the bed — and he reacts by going a little further: he relieves himself in the house. Or you're used to answering his requests for affection, and one day you're on the phone, busy, and you don't respond. He goes and relieves himself.
4. Separation anxiety
If your dog is clean the rest of the time and only has accidents in your absence, that's not a house-training problem at all — it's separation anxiety, and it needs to be addressed as such.
The real solution
Here's the principle behind the solution — it's broken down step by step in the course.
Pads, paper, crates — none of these fragile fixes actually work. What's redoubtably effective, and respects a dog's nature, is far simpler: apply a set of rules of life that governs his whole world — food, territory, contact, sexuality. That same framework that brings him balance is what resolves house-training problems, because it removes the power or the ambiguity that was causing them in the first place.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to house train a puppy?
It depends on his sphincter development, not just training. A 2-month-old puppy can rarely hold it more than 2 hours while awake; that capacity lengthens progressively — around 3 months, 3 to 4 hours, and so on. Taking him out after he drinks, plays, eats, or sleeps prevents most accidents during this period, even before he's fully clean.
Why is my dog peeing or pooping in the house?
If he's clean except when you're away, that's separation anxiety, not a house-training problem. Otherwise, once his sphincters are operational, it comes down to one of two causes: puppy pads that taught him the whole area was acceptable, or a hierarchical cause — either he holds power and is marking territory, or his status is ambiguous.
Do puppy pads work?
No — they're counterproductive. Using a pad teaches your dog that it's fine to relieve himself in the house in general, not just on the pad; he's praised for the whole area, not the pad itself. Once you remove the pad, most dogs keep going in that same spot, and you then have to block access to retrain it.
Why did my house-trained dog suddenly start having accidents again?
First, rule out a medical cause — though in practice it's rare. Otherwise, it's almost always hierarchical: you gave him power somewhere, like letting him on the couch, and then took it away elsewhere, like refusing the bed, or you stopped responding to a request for contact you used to answer.
Learn how to become your dog's leader — without treats and without pain — step by step, filmed with real dogs.
See the course
Stephan Mairesse