Stephan Mairesse ← All articles
Case study

The Tool You Were Sold Failed You, Not You: The Inaya Case Study

A Bull Terrier misdiagnosed as "bipolar or schizophrenic," facing a lifetime of psychiatric medication, was resolved in a single day — no drugs, no diagnosis needed. The owner wasn't the problem; the method she'd been sold was.

Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.

See the course

"It is not you who failed; the tool you were sold is simply unsuited to canine reality."

A few years ago, the owner of Inaya, a young female Bull Terrier, contacted me. She was desperate after seeking help from numerous professionals — trainers, behaviorists, and ultimately a highly renowned veterinarian whose diagnosis left her utterly shocked. While researching online, she came across my articles and asked me to travel to the south of France. As I began writing a new book, I asked her if I could share her story. Here is her reply:

It is wonderful to denounce these practices, and I congratulate you for it. If our experience can save families and their dogs, prevent false diagnoses, and stop abusive practices, it must of course be shared. The words of that "eminent" Doctor (a member of the European College of Veterinary Behavioural Medicine and author of four books) are still etched in my memory: according to him, we had to face facts — our dog was "at best bipolar, otherwise schizophrenic"! Following a consultation billed at 160 euros, we left completely stunned, handed a prescription for lifelong medication. He told us that depending on Inaya's reactions, we had at our disposal a wide range of mental illness products to administer... I genuinely felt like we were heading down the wrong path, I was completely lost... When I discovered your website, I felt as though it had been made specifically for us, and I understood that I had found the solution... I can never thank you enough for agreeing to travel to us and for saving us! How many dog owners remain helpless and trapped by the diagnoses of such veterinarians? How many dogs undergo psychiatric treatments or are euthanized when they are simply misunderstood or poorly guided?...

Inaya's owner

— After a single day spent with the owner, the problem was completely resolved.

1. The Great Illusion of the Commercial Transaction

This testimony alone summarizes the tragic drift of modern orthodoxy. Years of wandering, overwhelming guilt, consultations billed at top dollar by the discipline's heavyweights just to hear that a dog is "bipolarly or schizophrenically disordered," and an animal on the verge of being pumped full of psychotropic drugs for life.

Why do we reach this point? Because owners have been sold the illusion that educating a dog is a simple transaction: a piece of food in exchange for good behavior. But a genuine relationship between a human and a canid does not rest on a permanent exchange contract.

It relies on understanding the dog's true inner nature, an understanding that leads to establishing a living environment defined by essential rules of life indispensable to its balance.

By denying hierarchy and leaning into a "100% positive" approach, no limits or hierarchical framework are imposed on the dog. This is nothing less than promoting a purely anarchic system.

Eliminating clear landmarks, defined roles, and structure does not create a paradise of equality — it creates chaos.

This anarchic system is a complete utopia — and far beyond a mere illusion, it reveals a total ignorance of canine social organization. A dog cannot be educated or properly integrated into a social group solely through food offerings. Educating a dog requires vastly more than that. Viewing dog training as a simple matter of handing out food — while entirely lacking the fundamental living framework essential to its well-being — is an extraordinarily simplistic and flawed vision.

The day the dog's instinct — or simply the desire for an attraction stronger than food — overpowers its interest in swallowing a treat, this whole artificial system collapses. And facing that breakdown, rather than questioning the inadequacy of the tool, the dog is pathologized and the owner is left carrying unwarranted guilt.

2. True Well-Being: The Soothing Security of a Clear Framework

Contrary to the prevailing dogma that equates authority with abuse, restoring hierarchy and structure is not a punishment: it is an act of love and liberation.

A dog deprived of limits is trapped in a state of constant hyper-vigilance, consumed by anxiety and forced into a decision-making role it has neither the capacity nor the desire to shoulder.

By putting roles back in their proper place, by embodying a firm, fair, and protective guide, we free the animal from an immense weight. The dog finally finds peace of mind knowing that its human is responsible for it, and not the other way around. The human ensures the protection of the pack and the safety of the dog, offering it a serene and calm daily life.

3. Saving Lives and Restoring Household Peace

Inaya's case raises the crucial question her owner asked: how many dogs undergo treatments for alleged mental illnesses or are euthanized when they are simply misunderstood or poorly guided?

The toll of this "all-positive" ideology pushes tragedy to extremes. When we move past hypocrisy and reintroduce common sense, discipline, and hierarchical structure, the miracle of the field occurs — in a single day, the problem is solved, without a psychiatric prescription.

It is not you who failed. The tool you were sold is unsuited to canine reality. Never let anyone make you believe you are a bad owner because tiny bits of meat aren't enough to channel your dog's deep nature. You do not need a hesitant negotiator or a delusional psychiatric diagnosis; your dog needs a benevolent leader.

Restore the framework it needs, and you will restore peace — to your dog and to your home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a dog with behavior problems be mistaken for mental illness?

Yes. In Inaya's case, a veterinary behaviorist diagnosed a young Bull Terrier as "at best bipolar, otherwise schizophrenic" and prescribed lifelong psychiatric medication, after positive-only methods had failed to control her.

How fast can restoring hierarchy and leadership resolve severe anxiety-driven behavior?

In Inaya's case, the problem that had led to a psychiatric diagnosis and a lifelong medication prescription was fully resolved after a single day spent with the owner — without any medication.

Does restoring hierarchy mean being harsh with a dog?

No. Restoring hierarchy and structure is not a punishment — it relieves a dog of a decision-making role it has neither the capacity nor the desire to shoulder, and gives it the security of a clear, benevolent leader.

Why does relying only on food, without hierarchy, create problems?

Because a genuine relationship between a human and a dog doesn't rest on a permanent exchange of treats for behavior — it requires rules of life essential to the dog's balance. Eliminating structure doesn't create equality, it creates chaos, and the whole system collapses the moment something more interesting than food appears.

Stephan Mairesse

Stephan MairesseInternational Dog Trainer, 30 years of experience across 16 countries. Certification N°750108. Read his full background →

This is one piece of The Stephan Mairesse Method — the complete, no-treats, ethology-based obedience course.

See the course