Leash Reactive Dog and Treats Don't Work? Why — and How to Stop It (Video)
In short: If treats haven't worked on your leash-reactive dog, it isn't your fault: food cannot compete with what he's reacting to. Leadership is what you need — with the right obedience method, you become the ON/OFF switch. Bruno, reactive toward every dog, no longer reacted 20 minutes later, once his owner had mastered the heel.
Prefer a complete, step-by-step method filmed with real dogs — instead of piecing it together article by article? That's exactly what the course walks you through.
See the courseDoes your dog explode every time he sees another dog?
He barks, lunges, spins at the end of the leash. You cross the street, change your route, walk him late at night to avoid other dogs. You've tried treats, high-value treats, counter-conditioning — and the moment he sees another dog, he doesn't even look at them. And you've been told it will take months.
These clips are short excerpts. In the course, you watch the full sessions — unedited, step by step.
Who's talking? I'm Stephan Mairesse, an International Dog Trainer for 30 years. I've trained more than 2,000 dogs in private lessons, in sixteen countries, and I spent more than 10 years living with dog packs of 6 to 20 dogs at home. I worked on explosive-detection dog training alongside a commander of the RAID, the French National Police's special forces unit. Certification N°750108.
Why this is different
The results of my method are not only very fast, but also highly effective. Most online courses show dogs that already know how to obey, in edited clips that keep only the successful attempts. In my course, you watch dogs learn from scratch — refusals included — in real sessions, unedited, step by step, without treats.
Results at a glance
Real dogs, real problems, and the time it took — all filmed.
| Dog | Problem | Result | Time it took |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bruno (reactivity) | Reactive toward every dog | No more reactivity, with his owner | 20 minutes |
| Hugo | Had bitten several people, family and guests | Calm in the middle of other people, with his owner | 3 sessions |
| Sangha | Very aggressive | Calm the moment he is given the command | 2 or 3 sessions of 20 minutes |
| Bruno (heel) | Very reactive, on a crowded beach | Heels | A single lesson |
| Molly (heel) | A catastrophic start on the leash | An excellent heel | 2 sessions |
| Molly (recall) | No recall at all | Comes back immediately, among other dogs | 3 sessions |
| Coco | Afraid of everything on the street; her owners couldn't walk her | Walks calmly at heel | 3 outings of 10 minutes |
| Zorba | Chased scooters, still uncontrollable after 2 months with another trainer | No longer chases | 20 minutes |
| Ruby | Killed cats; nobody could approach her | Controlled in front of prey; can be approached and touched | 3 sessions |
For comparison: in a published study of 441 very fearful shelter dogs, behavior modification took an average of 78 sessions over 96 days — with medication as a complement (Collins et al., 2022).
“A treat is a trade, not obedience.”
Stephan Mairesse
Why is my dog reactive on the leash?
Because he's stuck in a high state of arousal, and nobody controls him. A dog in a high state of excitement is completely normal in certain circumstances. It only becomes "reactivity" when the dog, because his owner doesn't control him, stays stuck in that state. There are usually three different reasons behind it.
The first is that your dog feels diminished by the leash itself. A leash removes his freedom of movement — and instinctively, a weakened dog with no way to escape tends to attack preemptively to defend himself, since fleeing isn't an option. You can see this for yourself: unclip the leash, and in many cases, the aggression stops immediately. That's the proof — it was the restraint itself triggering the reaction, not the other dog.
The second is a dog with a strong temperament, who naturally wants to assert his authority over other dogs.
The third is the opposite: a dog without much natural temperament, but who has been given the power at home because nobody leads him. By default, he ends up in charge of the group — and he reacts as if that were his job, because as far as he's concerned, it is.
In all three cases, the common thread is the same: leadership is what you need. Without it, from your dog's point of view, he has no reason to listen to you.
Not all leash reactivity is aggression, though. If your dog lunges because he wants to chase a cat, a scooter, or anything that moves, that's a different mechanism — prey drive — and the cause is much simpler: disobedience. See how to stop a high prey drive dog for that specific case.
Some trainers call this "fear-based" reactivity — but that label is where a lot of behavioral analysis loses its precision. A dog who reacts because he feels diminished by the leash (the first reason, above) isn't a fearful dog: that's a normal defensive reflex, the same one any dog would have when restrained. And a genuinely fearful dog doesn't suddenly start attacking another dog out of nowhere — that's not how fear works. His default is to flee: that's Coco's case, in the table above — freezing, refusing to move, trying to flee, pulling against the leash to get away, never toward anything.
What's really happening with dogs who attack systematically on the leash — including ones who were naturally timid to begin with — is the third reason, above: nobody leads them, so they end up in charge of the group by default. A dog placed in that role has a job to do, and he does it, setting his fear aside because defending the group is now his responsibility — not because he spontaneously found courage on his own. Trainers who call this "fear-based" are often the ones who can't properly read aggression: they fold everything into fear instead of seeing the real mechanism, which is control.
"Frustration-based" reactivity is simpler still: a dog who hasn't learned to obey pulls toward whatever he wants, because nothing stops him. Across all of these — the normal defensive reflex, the dog thrust into a leadership role he isn't suited for, and the untrained dog pulling toward what he wants — the fix isn't a label. It's obedience, and being the one who decides for your dog.
Why don't treats work for a reactive dog?
Because when your dog is reactive, he won't pay the slightest attention to your treat. Food simply cannot compete with deep instinctual drives — prey drive, intense fear, territorial defense.
For 30 years, I have been explaining why food-reward training is ineffective the moment a dog is strongly attracted to or stimulated by something else. A treat is a trade, not obedience. What stops reactivity is obedience — real obedience, the kind your dog cannot ignore.
What does the ON/OFF switch mean?
When your dog obeys the heel or the down, his reactivity stops. Both commands are a way to switch it off. The dog who was barking and lunging a second earlier is calm the moment he obeys — that is the deep power of obedience. Time to teach these commands: 2 or 3 sessions of 20 minutes.
The same switch works inside your home: see how obedience stops a dog who is aggressive at home.
How to stop leash reactivity
Here's the principle behind the solution — it's broken down step by step in the course.
Use positive reinforcement generously — but if you never introduce some discomfort, your dog will never obey you properly.
Discomfort was never my choice: if treats worked, I would use them. And in the dog's world, when a dog wants to impose something on another — to lie down, to stay in a corner — he does it physically.
- Establish your leadership at home first. Through the rules of life and the four pillars of hierarchy: food, territory, contact and sexuality. Without leadership, your dog has no reason to listen to you.
- Teach real obedience in a calm place. Heel and down, with positive reinforcement and some discomfort when he disobeys.
- Then use obedience in front of the trigger. Another dog, a scooter, a person: the command becomes the ON/OFF switch.
What not to do
These are the mistakes that keep a dog reactive:
- Don't accept results "over time". If a method only promises results over time, is it one week, one month, or one year?
- Don't start in front of the trigger. Teach obedience in a calm place first. Then use it where your dog reacts.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to stop leash reactivity?
Bruno, reactive toward every dog, no longer reacted 20 minutes later, once his owner had mastered the heel. Teaching the commands that switch reactivity off takes 2 or 3 sessions of 20 minutes. That's the kind of result you can get too.
How do I stop my dog from being reactive on the leash?
Establish your leadership at home, teach real obedience in a calm place, then use it in front of the trigger: heel or down become the ON/OFF switch. How that's built step by step is taught in the course.
My reactive dog won't take treats when he sees another dog. What should I do?
Stop trying to compete with what he's reacting to: food can't win against deep instinctual drives. What works is obedience. When he obeys the heel or the down, his reactivity stops.
Does counter-conditioning with treats work for leash reactivity?
It promises results "over time" — one week, one month, or one year. The videos above show what obedience does instead, without a single treat.
Can an aggressive dog really calm down instantly?
Yes. Sangha is very aggressive when he isn't asked to obey, and immediately calm the moment he's given the command. Watch the video above.
Why is my dog aggressive on the leash but fine off-leash?
Because the leash itself removes his freedom of movement, and a dog who feels he can't get away tends to attack preemptively to defend himself. Unclip the leash, and in many cases the aggression stops immediately — proof that the restraint was the trigger, not the other dog. The fix isn't avoiding the leash; it's leadership, so your dog isn't left to defend himself in the first place.
References (APA 7th Edition)
- Collins, K., Miller, K., Zverina, L., Patterson-Kane, E., Cussen, V., & Reid, P. (2022). Behavioral rehabilitation of extremely fearful dogs: Report on the efficacy of a treatment protocol. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 254, Article 105689. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2022.105689
Stop struggling with a reactive dog.
The complete obedience training is in my online course: over 3.5 hours of step-by-step video training, filmed with dogs that had never been trained, plus a 101-page companion manual. Module 8 covers reactivity, aggression, fear and the other behavior problems.
See the course — €249
Stephan Mairesse